Friday, May 22, 2026

Creative Hands "ClayStudio" Polymer Clay from Hobby Lobby - Review - May 22, 2026

Yesterday, I yielded to temptation and went to Hobby Lobby to get a little more polymer clay, "just a couple of packs" to enable me to make something I'd seen in a tutorial.

I already had a couple of 2-oz packs of Sculpey clay in my basket (at roughly $3.50 per pack) when I noticed another brand of polymer clay - Creative Hands ClayStudio" - hanging above the Sculpey.  There were six 2-ounce packages of clay in each box, and there were four color themes - warm, cool, primary, and neutral colors.  Each box of clay cost $9.99.  My razor-sharp math brain calculated the price of each pack of ClayStudio clay to be a little over a dollar-something per pack.  On top of that, there was a sign that said, "Clay 40% off."  SOLD!  I bought a box of each color theme.

I wasn't sure the 40% discount applied to ALL clay, so when I got to the cashier, I asked if the ClayStudio clay was part of the sale.  The cashier said that the clay sale didn't start until Monday.   I said, "But there's a sign...."  She paged the manager, he checked (and took down the sign), and I got - 24 2-ounce packs of clay for $23.something.  SCORE!  

When I got home, I googled the brand and found only one mention of this clay, a short video made by someone who had bought the brand at Dollar Tree.  The video said that the clay was very soft and sticky, with the consistency of already-been-chewed gum.  

I opened a pack and began to condition it by rolling/folding it in my hands.  It was sticky straight out of the package, and the color was uneven.  I tried rolling it through my pasta machine.  Instead of coming out smooth, it looked . . . leprous.  I was able to get it smooth with an acrylic roller, but it was impossible to lift it off a tile without stretching it, and impossible to get it out of a cutter without mangling it.  

Eventually, I made a pendant and some earrings, all of which were misshapen by the time I took them to the oven.  The package said to bake them at 250 for 15 minutes.  My pieces were about 1/4" thick.  I was afraid that 15 minutes was not long enough, so I baked them for 30 minutes.  Left to cool overnight, when I attempted to sand them, they crumbled.  

This morning, I tried again.  I skipped the whole conditioning process and tried just rolling out the clay with a roller.  It was sticky.  When I tried to cut out a shape, the edges came out ragged.  At this moment, I have a 1/2" thick log of the clay on a tile in the refrigerator to see if cooling the clay will make it easier to handle.  I probably should have made a slab instead of a roll so that I could get straight to the cutting.

We'll see.  

Admittedly, I am not an expert at handling clay, but I cannot give this clay a passing grade.


No comments:

Post a Comment